The year was 1937; Joe Russell had a heated dispute when then-landlord Isaac Wolkowsky raised the rent on the bar from three dollars a week to a whopping four dollars a week. Joe was so incensed that he decided to move, but a clause in his lease prohibited him from removing any of the furnishings and other accoutrements in the bar. Russell wasn’t going to let a little thing like that stop him. Before long, the determined saloonkeeper solidified his strategy when his lease expired. He soon purchased the nearby vacant Victoria Restaurant building on the corner of Duval and Greene Streets from Juan Farto for $2,500. The majestic building had been built in 1917 and incorporated beautiful Cuban tile floors, whirling ceiling fans, and jalousie doors.
On May 5, 1937, Sloppy Joe’s Bar seemingly disappeared. Wolkowsky, away on a trip, returned to find he was no longer Russell's landlord. With patrons' help, Joe Russell moved down the block and across to the new quarters at 201 Duval Street. The migration was a true Key West spectacle, as customers carried their drinks and the furnishings to the new location. Service resumed quickly with refreshments on the house – the new house – for the rest of the night.
Upon hearing of the move, Hemingway remarked, "Only in Key West."
Sloppy Joe’s Bar’s address may have changed, and its square footage nearly doubled, but its atmosphere remained the same. It boasted the longest bar in town, a walled-off room often used for gambling, and a 119-pound sailfish caught by Hemingway adorning one wall.
If you, like those patrons 87 years ago, are lucky enough to be in Key West on May 5th, join us for an all-day celebration on those same Cuban tile floors.